Numerous states have recently tightened rules regarding food stamps and unemployment insurance. Now a bunch of them are imposing new requirements on welfare recipients.
Understanding both the pros and the cons of it means that there is no black and white answer when it comes to the best solution. Some states have had these programs in place and they suffered greatly trying to implement them.
Florida, for one state, has implemented drug testing of studentswhich has proven to be another boondoggle. Pros It is possible that the risk of losing welfare benefits would result in fewer people using drugs.
If they have the money to pay for drugs they should have money to pay for their own living expenses is often the way of thinking on this one.
A positive drug test for someone receiving welfare can be the first step to them getting help. With this line of intervention it can mean that the person is able to get the counseling and substance abuse help that they need in order to turn their life around. In some states, recipients of welfare funds have already taken the programs to court.
They feel their rights have been violated. In some states, the ruling has come back that these mandatory drug tests are unconstitutional. Cons Many people worry that taking away the welfare benefits due to an adult failing a drug test only makes that household suffer more poverty.
It can also mean the adults turn to illegal activities in order to pay for their drug habits. It can be very expensive to implement successful drug testing programs for welfare recipients. The program has to determine who will be tested and when they will be tested.
Will it be random or will it be on a regular basis? What type of testing will be done and what will the collection process be?
What will the repercussions be for someone that refuses to be tested? There are plenty of issues that have to be addressed for the program. Funding is a serious barrier to these types of programs. In order for the funding to be there, taxpayers would have to agree to paying more than they already do.
Which Leads Us Here Only time will tell if the issue of drug testing welfare recipients becomes the norm or not. Many of the taxpayers are all for this process, though. There are plenty of advocates on both sides of this issue.
Which could lead one to ponder about what kind of logic leads to these short-sighted laws. Some might think the obvious answer might be politicians pandering to an uninformed constituency. Who benefits from all of this? The lawyers win, for one group. They will keep the courts clogged up for the foreseeable future.
The testing labs will surely benefit, as well. Another group, that flies low under the radar, is the industry that sells solutions designed to get somebody a passing grade on the drug test. Manipulating the results of a drug test is not as easy as it once was.
The industry offers various methods or processes to thwart detection. They should see an uptick in their business in states where welfare recipients are being tested.
Who Loses The folks being tested and their families lose, for one. The folks who might grow a little pot on their own, at no cost, lose too.
Two weeks later when they fail a drug screen and lose their benefits because of their smoking some weed two weeks ago —everything changes. Whose business is it? Recent visitors have also viewed:Mar 05, · This is the driving sentiment behind what we are seeing throughout the country, a mass movement among Republicans at the state and federal level to implement welfare drug testing .
Persuasive essay about drug testing Drug Testing Welfare Recipients - Duration: by. Drug Testing In Schools: Debate Paper - With A Free Essay Review - Free Essay Reviews. Stop biting on your nails and trying to come up with topics for persuasive essay. There’s a great.
Jun 30, · Persuasive Speech - Drug Testing for Welfare Recipients Taylor Leavitt.
Drug Testing Catches Shocking Number Welfare Recipients - Duration: Essay . Download thesis statement on Welfare and Drug Testing in our database or order an original thesis paper that will be written by one of our staff writers and delivered according to the deadline.
States have proposed drug testing of applicants and recipients of public welfare benefits since federal welfare reform in The federal rules permit drug testing as part of the Temporary Assistance for Needy Families block grant. Out of 38, welfare applicants, 48 people got positive drug tests in Missouri.
Utah blew $64, to catch 29 people who did llegal drugs. Arizona found 3, and Mississippi just 2.